Unity Behind the Wrong Principles Is No Achievement
We are currently in a war for the heart and soul of the Republican Party of Texas. This war is being
fought in nearly every one of the 254 counties in Texas. While most see the factions involved as the
same, they actually fight for two very different futures for Texas.
One faction in this war refers to itself as “Grassroots Conservatives” or sometimes “America-First”
or “Texas-First” conservatives. Currently, this faction controls the direction of the state party,
though only a few Grassroots Conservatives hold state office. Well-representing the Grassroots
agenda, the Republican Party of Texas (RPT) Platform reflects a focus on first principles: individual
liberty, limited government, Christian family values, and Texas sovereignty. Grassroots
Conservatives are typically outspoken and often non-compromising on matters of principle. They
demand that our Republican elected officials align with our platform and gracefully hold
themselves to term limits.
The other faction has no name for itself other than Republican. The Grassroots refer to it as “The
Establishment.” The aim of the Establishment is to ensure that the Establishment Republicans that
are in office, stay in office. Their rhetoric accomplishes this by fearmongering with the threat of
Democrats taking control. The Establishment accuses the Grassroots of being a divisive force
within the Republican party, as if we would be better off if we all mindlessly supported anyone with
an “(R)” after their name, whether or not they fought to secure Republican Priorities.
The divide between the two factions is ideological. The Establishment opposes, to varying degrees
but often quite openly, many of the planks of the RPT Platform. Many in the Establishment are fine
with normalizing relations with clubs like the Log Cabin Republicans, which seek to eliminate the
long-held stance of the RPT that marriage can only exist between one man and one woman.
Similarly, the Establishment, by and large, has no issue financing campaigns with liberal lobbies
such as:
Texans for Public Education
promotes and supports CRT, SEL, and comprehensive sex education, and viciously
opposes RPT Priorities like School Choice
Associated Republicans of Texas
since 2018, focused on helping the Establishment win primaries against
conservatives. Board members even donated about a half million dollars to
democrats in recent years, including Robert “Beto” O’Rourke
Chickasaw Nation
promotes the legalization of gambling
Texas REALTORS/Texans for Lawsuit Reform
instrumental in killing legislation that would have protected Texans from vaccine
mandates
Border Health PAC
fought hard against protecting children from being subjected to chemical and
surgical castration by their parents
Texas Alliance for Life
lobby that supports only Establishment candidates, and which strongly opposes state
legislation that would abolish abortion in Texas
2
These benign sounding lobbies, and many more like them, are at the top of every Establishment
Republican’s donor list and are indeed as likely to fund Democrats as they are Republicans.
While claiming that they are in favor of unity, the Establishment harbors an intense animosity
against the Grassroots. In fact, the Establishment fights harder against Grassroots Conservatives
than against Democrats. Establishment Republicans conspicuously redistricted House District 92
and House District 73 to eliminate Grassroots Conservatives Jeff Cason and Kyle Biedermann,
actually ceding the former district to the Democrats. During the last primary, establishment
Republicans such as Dade Phelan, Glenn Rogers, and Lynn Stucky repeatedly doubled down in
their support of putting Democrats in charge of powerful committees, while Grassroots
Conservative-backed incumbents such as Bryan Slaton, Jeff Cason, and Matt Schaeffer argued
against the practice. Even the Freedom Caucus, which has not enjoyed much Grassroots support
recently, came out openly against the practice of putting Democrats in Committee Chair positions
during the 2022 Republican Primary.
During the 86th Texas Legislative regular session, 473 new laws were passed. 41% of these laws
moved federal statute and regulation into state law. Grassroots Conservatives voted against the vast
majority of these bills. Establishment Republicans carried them. Grassroots Conservatives opposed
Governor Abbott’s closure of churches, courts, businesses, and schools. The first three were open
violations of the Texas Bill of Rights. The Establishment, instead, thanked Governor Abbott for his
brave use of power. Grassroots Republicans begged to be liberated from forced vaccinations by
business owners. Establishment Republicans opposed such legislation, instead leaning on Governor
Abbott’s use of Executive Order that would never hold up in court.
Door-to-door, Republicans have no horse in this fight. Most don’t even know that this war rages.
However, if you ask average Texas Republicans, “do you support the right of parents to change
their kids' gender?” By far the vast majority say emphatically “no!” If you asked them if Democrats
should be in charge, they say, “hell no!” If you ask them if they are in favor of Texans deciding
what is best for Texas, or if they are for or against the globalist agenda, they would generally lean
toward you and say “well if we’re honest, I think Texas should be a country again.” They would
laugh, but under that there is a seriousness about Texas which is palpable.
On March 1st, Texas Republicans resoundingly affirmed Grassroots positions on ballot propositions
regarding a number of important issues:
93% believe that Texas should secure its own border, using the Texas Military Forces and
state law enforcement to enforce immigration laws in spite of the federal government.
Establishment legislators have opposed this at every turn, and the Governor currently defers
to federal immigration authority over the Texas border.
77% believe that the property taxes should be eliminated. Establishment legislators have
given this nothing but lip service for a decade.
85% believe that businesses should not be able to force employees to take a vaccine. The
Establishment fought and killed bills that would have protected Texans throughout the 87th
Legislative session.
83% believe that abortion should be abolished in Texas. Establishment legislators, while
claiming to be against abortion, are strongly against legislation that would define the unborn
as human beings entitled to equal protection under the law. Legislation that would have
done just this was not even given a hearing by Establishment Republicans last session.
81% believe that Democrats should not chair committees in the Texas Legislature. Nearly
all Establishment legislators support giving Democrats power.
3
There are profound ideological differences in play. Ask a room full of Establishment Republicans if
they believe January 6 was an insurrection. A large percentage will say it was. Do this at a
grassroots conservative club, and you will see no hands at all. When you boil the bones of this
conflict down, the true difference between Establishment and Grassroots Republicans is the former
are often Hamiltonian globalists who have a general trust of government, while the latter
exemplifies a deeply Jeffersonian distrust of any centralized power.
It is the premise of the Establishment that Republicans are stronger if the tent is bigger. They
believe that If we simply agree-to-disagree on many of these important issues (i.e., ceding our
platform to the Establishment at the local and state level), that we will be stronger and better able to
defeat the Democrats each year. Grassroots Conservatives, however, will simply not be part of a
party that supports same-sex marriage, opposes school choice, or allows that there are scenarios that
the government can force you to be vaccinated. It is not theoretical. Abandon our principles and,
like California, the only ones left in the RPT will be those who believe that the party’s main
purpose is to beat Democrats, instead of standing for our Constitution which was founded on Judeo-
Christian values.
The purpose of government is to protect the liberties and property of the people. Period. There is no
other purpose. Government does not exist to keep us safe. The aim of political activism and
involvement is no different. We all take time out of our busy lives to fight for the liberty of our
children. These are not social clubs, and there is nothing to be gained by feigned solidarity. Either
what we believe to be right and good and true under God, is right and good and true, or we should
oppose it. There is no compromise when it comes to freedom, and why would we naturally expect
anything but discord when debating truth? For Jesus told us, “Do you suppose that I came to
give peace on earth? I tell you, not at all, but rather division. For from now on five in one
house will be divided: three against two, and two against three” (Luke 12:49).
It is totally natural and healthy that the fight for our ideals will be vocal, animated and, at times,
combative. Our very liberty is at stake. It is appropriate that we are passionate and persuasive but
never deferential or acquiescent under the pretended patriotism of “unity.” Unity over anything
other than Godly truth is no achievement whatsoever.
In Liberty,
Wise County Conservatives
Grayson County Conservatives
4
Denton County Conservative Coalition
JoAnn Flemming with
We The People Grassroots Amaerica
Lamar County Conservatives
True Texas Project
Cooke County Conservatives